The focus of posts will be my Civil War travels with a healthy dose of Shiloh related research.
Monday, July 26, 2010
15th United States Infantry
Killed:
Daniel Butler (A), Ashmer Gatten (A), First Sergeant H. Keeling (H) and Joshua Provost (C).
Wounded:
John C .Dolta (A), A. Fisher (A), T. Jourdin (A), C.W. Kridler (A), J.H. Lemon (A), Sergeant Paul McShane (A), Peter McVeetry (A), H.C. Smith (A), Martin Van Suttle (A), Jacob Warrick (A), George W. Bettis (B), John Burns (B), August Faul (B), James Langan (B), William H. McGill (B), Corporal J. McGregory (B), Nicholas Powell (B), Henry Wedemyer (B), Henry Barry (C), Tim H. Johnson (C), William Landis (C), Robert Marshall (C), Philip Sep (C), Corporal Tittsworth (C), Corporal J.W. Whitlock (C), First Sergeant John Williams (C), Corporal G.M. Parrett (D), Louis Statler (D), Justice Wyman (D), P. Cardle (E), James Closs (E), Corporal William Fitch (E), Captain Henry Keteltas (E), John Thomas McKinzie (E), G. Newcomb (E), Corporal F. Temmens (E), First Lieutenant Charles A. Wikoff (E), John Burk (F), Enoch Fritter (F), Captain John C. Peterson (F), Louis Plitt (F), Harrison Toy (F), David S. Carson (G), Aug. F. Enterman (G), First Sergeant M. Kiggins (G), Corporal Emanuel Kretzer (G), McLean (G), Christopher Morris (G), David L. Ship (G), Charles Troutman (G), Edmund Warren (G), Captain James Curtiss (H), Sergeant John Gleeson (H), William Hoover (H), Robert Howell (H) and Ligget (H).
Missing:
Corporal Green Gibson (F).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 246-7
The Chickamauga Campaign
Western theater battles often lack the coverage that Eastern theater battles do. This discrepancy will never be erased but lately there has been a surge of Western Theater material. Partially trying to fill this void is the Civil War Campaigns in Heartland series from Southern Illinois University Press. The second volume, covering the Chickamauga campaign, follows on the heels of the wonderful Shiloh volume published last year.
Editor Steven E. Woodworth has assembled eight essays that explore some aspects of the campaign and provoke some critical thinking. The collection of essays focuses more on the Confederate side than the Union side. There are essays on D. H. Hill, Alexander Stewart, James Longstreet, Patrick Cleburne’s night assault, James Negley’s actions on Horseshoe Ridge, the performances of Thomas Crittenden and Alexander McCook, the near battle of McLemore’s Cove and Henry Van Ness Boynton’s shaping of Chickamauga as a national park. Although the collection focuses more on the Confederates it is not a distracting decision especially since the essay on Crittenden and McCook is nearly three times the length of the other essays, so the page count is probably pretty closely divided.
All the essays were good, there did not seem to be a weak one in the collection. There are four maps at the front of the book. Although it is nice to have maps these are not the best maps as all troop locations are shown as a horizontal box. On a theater map this is fine but on a battlefield map this makes it appear as if all troops were facing north or south. Some maps from contributor David Powell’s recent “Maps of Chickamauga” would have been better.
The problems with the maps though are easily overlooked though because of what a wonderful collection of essays this is. With two volumes in the Campaigns in Heartland series completed this series is now established as one to pay attention to for all future installments.
Contributors were John R. Lundberg, Alexander Mendoza, David Powell, Ethan S. Rafuse, William G. Robertson, Timothy B. Smith, Lee White, and Steven E. Woodworth.
The full review will be posted after its publication in Civil War News.
Friday, July 23, 2010
81st Ohio Infantry
The Ever-Changing Leaders and Organization of the Army of the Potomac
I made a previous post about this book, the author had emailed me trying to sell a copy and made the claim that there were 6 changes in army command and the 8 changes in general-in-chief. He made a big point in the email (and on the back of the book) about saying how many changes there were among the leaders and the organization of the army. The back of the book proclaims 149 changes in leadership and 94 changes in organization.
I thought he was overreaching on both points. Even if we consider McDowell a commander of the Army of the Potomac (he technically wasn't because it wasn't the Army of the Potomac yet but many authors will credit him as the first commander because his army is the basis for the Army of the Potomac) that leaves us with five; McDowell, McClellan, Burnside, Hooker and Meade. And those are truthfully only four changes. But Maharay claims Pope as a commander of the Army of the Potomac, giving him a tenure of "six days or less" as commander. This is obviously wrong. Not to belabor a point but McClellan was not relieved of command in late August 1862, he had many of his men temporarily transferred to Pope's command. And if Pope had won the battle of Second Manassas I'm sure those transfers would have become permanent and McClellan would have been sent home. But he retained command of the army until November 1862. And Pope was never given command of the Army of the Potomac, just over many of its men. There is also the possibility that if the two armies were combined under a victorious Pope that the new army would be called the Army of Virginia (the name of Pope's army, who would the victors choose the name of the army that had been defeated in all of its major battles?)
His logic for the general in chief post is even more convoluted, he claims times when Lincoln was general in chief and times when Lincoln and Halleck held the post jointly. Both are false. There definitely were times when Lincoln did Halleck's job but he was never officially general in chief. I thought his email might have been mostly exaggerated to sell books but he actually says in the text that Lincoln was general in chief.
I think this book had the chance to be great, and some of it is worthwhile. Partly it is his interpretations of things that weaken the book. In the chapter discussing Grant becoming general in chief and electing to keep his headquarters near the Army of the Potomac instead of at a desk in Washington Maharay does a good job of explaining the situation and the decision. Then near the end of the book when recapping all the commanders of the army he writes this one sentence paragraph to close the chapter, "US Grant took to the field with the Army of the Potomac and from March 1864 until the end of the war, the army had two commanders." There were times Meade felt that he wasn't really commanding the army but on paper he was still the commander, his commanding officer just happened to always be very close by. Maharay did a good job explaining that setup the first time it appeared and then made an error the second time around.
The author is really devoted to numbering the changes, closing each chapter with a list of the changes and numbering them. I'm not so sure that his figures of 149 changes in leadership and 94 changes in organization are correct. For example when Burnside replaces McClellan as commander of the army this is counted as two changes, McClellan being relieved and Burnside replacing him. Same thing when McClellan replaces Scott as general in chief, Maharay counts it as two, Scott retiring and McClellan replacing him. This would make me believe that the number of changes is more likely half or two-thirds of the 149 and 94 Maharay claims. The actual number is not something I care about but when the author makes a big deal about numbering them then I feel he should be accurate.
I would have liked to see Maharay expand the book down to the divisional level. The book only focuses on the changes at the corps level and beyond. That's another reason the 149 and 94 changes claim seems way too high. That is a ton of changes for the corps and beyond level. At the most there were eight corps in the army at one moment. I made a chart from Maharay's info and it has 38 men making 49 command changes. This ignores the times that wings were used but those would not add more than a dozen command changes.
The book is self published. I've seen more of these in recent years and being self published doesn't necessarily make it a bad book. What seems to be lacking in them is the extensive review process many other presses put their books through. I know the University of Tennessee Press uses two peer reviewers who only worry about content and not grammar. A self published book could plenty of peer review as well as copy editing, instead though they seem to lack this. This book is a prime example.
A peer reviewer would have seen the issues I listed above and while they might not have been fixed they most likely would have been addressed more. Instead of a one sentence paragraph claiming Grant and Meade were both army commanders, 50 pages after a well reasoned section on the structure, the peer reviewer would have likely pressed Maharay to change that sentence or to enlarge the paragraph and explain why in his opinion Grant can be classified an army commander. I doubt that this book as is would have been published by a university press or one of the other good presses around the country. They might have eventually published the book but it would have looked different than it does now.
I'm glad I got this book through the library and did not spend my own $28 on it. I would not recommend anyone using their own money on this book.
Wednesday, July 21, 2010
Louisianians in the Western Confederacy: The Adams-Gibson Brigade in the Civil War
Stuart Salling’s book on the Adams-Gibson Brigade of Louisianians follows the brigade as it fought in the Army of Tennessee, participating in all the battles of that army until after Nashville when it was transferred to Mobile Bay rather than being sent to North Carolina. The brigade also served as part of Joe Johnston’s army in Mississippi during the summer of 1863.
The brigade went through many reorganizations but its main elements were banded together in August 1862. The ravages of war reduced the Louisiana regiments to the point that they had to be consolidated together, and sometimes they were able to gain enough recruits to regain their individual status again. Salling does a good job of explaining the plentiful confusing command and structure changes with the regiments of the brigade.
Salling also does a good job of explaining the political infighting between Bragg and his generals. Brigade commander Daniel Adams was a Bragg supporter, in fact he received this brigade to prevent Randall Gibson, a Bragg opponent, from commanding a brigade. Adams and Gibson though appear to have gotten along quite nicely. After Bragg resigned following the battle of Missionary Ridge Adams was one of the many officers who recommended Gibson for a promotion to brigadier general, which he got. Gibson commanded the brigade in all its future actions
Besides being an interesting story the book is laid out well visually. There are quite a few pictures of the men and officers who served in the brigade. The maps are nice as they show the layout of the regiments within the brigade and also show the entire battlefield as well. Sometimes these sorts of books get so focused on the activities of their small part that they ignore the larger operations, this book tends to do a good job of not getting too focused.
The full review will appear after its publication in Civil War News.
78th Ohio Infantry
Monday, July 19, 2010
77th Ohio Infantry
Killed:
Second Lieutenant JJ Steenrod (A), Jacob Maurer (A), Albert Kearnes (A), John Dongle (A), Sergeant WL Poterfield (B), Corporal George A Boothe (B), Clinton Dilley (B), Andrew Brown (B), John Wolford (B), Sergeant John Sandford (C), Corporal Jacob Batten (C), Daniel Lowrey (C), Orderly Sergeant James Fleming (D), FF Cottle (D), Sampson Coon (D), Benjamin Hughes (D), Corporal John K Hepburn (E), Daniel Shoup (E), Andrew Williams (E), John Seaber (E), Peter Brandon (E), Emaunuel Linkin (F), Alexander Reynolds (F), John Stoneman (F), Orderly Sergeant AJ Duvall (G), Corporal Daniel Sipple (G), Corporal George Cavanaugh (G), Thomas G Hill (G), Nicholas Roth (G), Mathias Noffsinger (G), Jacob Keukker (G), Jacob Steudle (G), James Baker (G), Sergeant Benjamin F Kimberly (H), Corporal Easly (H), Corporal Wyss (H), Corporal Henkie (H), Francis Burris (H), John Burris (H), Reuben Corn (H), James Hardin (H), Royal Wright (H), John Detwiller (H), James Brabham (K), Thomas Waller (K), Amos Suppler (K), Hugh A Davis (K) and David Davis (K).
Wounded:
John Paskel (A), Ezra Phillips (A), Joseph Hoskins (A), Joseph Harmon (A), David Bosman (A), Henry Keifer (A), Christian Rodocker (A), Sergeant Benjamin F Hill (A), Corporal Francis Mosena (A), Julius Wendland (B), Willard Davis (B), Frederick Booth (B), Henry W Hutchinson (B), Albert W Davis (B), Cornelius Grey (B), Robert Scott (B), Hiram McGee (B), Corporal Wylyss Thomily (B), Corporal James P Dougherty (B), First Lieutenant Mitchell (C), Orderly Sergeant JW Marlow (C), Nathaniel Webber (C), Samuel Bruce (C), Alexander Thomas (C), James Beaver (C), Calvin Beaver (C), Milton Beigle (C), Sergeant Jesse Grey (D), Sergeant John Cline (D), Corporal EA McPeek (D), Corporal GW Kidwell (D), Corporal John Morris (D), Robert H Fleming (D), WT Ables (D), John Cougleton (D), James Walker (D), John McEnrany (D), B Martin (D), B Masters (D), J Masters (D), C Pierce (D), BF Corp (D), John Bartlett (D), CM Steward (D), James Hoffman (D), Peter Coon (D), Christian Bowman (D), John Ingran (D), First Lieutenant Thomas Ganett (E), Sergeant LM Sinclair (E), Corporal Thomas Anderson (E), Corporal George W Williams (E), Corporal Thomas B Crozier (E), Corporal Israel R Heath (E), Corporal James M Baker (E), Benjamin T Dunlap (E), Francis Pitner (E), George Johnson (E), Austin Gill (E), William Chance (E), Joseph Hubbs (E), Edward Burnes (E), James A Dunfre (E), First Lieutenant HB White (F), Thomas Hale (F), Senica Colerick (F), Jesse Slewlynn (F), John Rowland (F), Lahureth Davis (F), Jacob Eddlebberte (F), Patrick Bustrow (F), William B Hinton (F), Second Lieutenant OS Thomas (G), Second Lieutenant Anthony Coon (G), Corporal George Myers (G), Corporal Benjamin Scott (G), Joseph Stukey (G), Edward Mathers (G), Hiram A Blouir (G), John Voshel (G), Alexander Smith (G), Second Lieutenant LJ Fourdker (H), Orderly Sergeant JP Calvert (H), Sergeant Brabham (H), Sergeant Isenbarth (H), Sergeant Fouaker (H), John Casserman (H), Lewis Fouraker (H), Jacob Miller (H), William Porter (H), Andrew Walters (H), Levi Yoss (H), Marcus Dillon (H), Percival Nott (H), First Lieutenant William Scott (I), Corporal James Thomas (I), William Crow (I), John Givens (I), Josiah Heren (I), Christopher Powell (I), Otty Powell (I), Corporal Peter Daly (I), Esau McVey (I), Wilson Verner (I), Lieutenant WH Fisher (K), Sergeant Thomas J Parks (K), Sergeant Nathan B Smith (K), John Dobbins (K), Michael Lyons (K), Brown A Davis (K), William Wilson (K), George Shivers (K) and John Mannifold (K).
Missing:
William Burton (A), John Koler (A), William Echols (A), John Yardly (B), Edwin W Deming (B), William B Perkins (B), William C Rutter (B), Thomas J McVey (B), William Smithson (B), Thomas Ferguson (C), Buell Filly (C), Joseph Higgins (C), William Authurs (C), Theodore Mead (C), Second Lieutenant H Criswell (E), Edward Kinney (E), Charles J Bloom (E), John F Broxton (E), Robert Knox (E), Thomas McCormick (E), Dennis Hogan (E), William Robinson (E), William Craig (E), George M Breach (F), Captain AW McCormick (G), Corporal Thomas Davis (G), George G Thomas (G), Solomon Youdlly (G), William Haught (G), Alexander Nugent (G), John Kanzig (G), Corporal McKenna (H), JJ Burris (H), Alb Burris (H), Worden Gossit (H), David Power (H), John Soland (H), George Young (H), Aaron Hoover (H), Captain Alvert Chandler (K), Sergeant Thomas M Addis (K), Corporal Thomas J Brabham (K), Corporal Peter B Keith (K), George Masters (K), Samuel Donaldson (K), James Grandstaff (K), Charles W Delaney (K), Samuel D Shivun (K), Samuel Henderson (K), Anthony Allen (K), Levi J Friel (K), Moses Adams (K), Stephen D Mathews (K), Charles W Wharf (K), Paul W Davis (K) and Nathan Shockley (K).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 129-31
Friday, July 16, 2010
76th Ohio Infantry
Killed:
William A Glass (F)
[1] Not in Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. List of killed and wounded online. Official Roster of the Soldiers of the State of Ohio in the War of the Rebellion 1861-1866. Cincinnati: Wilstach, Baldwin & Co., 1886. Vol 6, pp 255-96, 735-42.
Wednesday, July 14, 2010
72nd Ohio Infantry
Killed:
Lieutenant Colonel Herman Canfield, Captain Michael Wegstaim (H), Jacob Duesler (A), Hiram Plain (A), Samuel Shuck (A), Jacob Worst (B), Frederick Martin (B)[2], Henry Ernest (D), Corporal Christian Witiner (D), Samuel Wiseman (D)[3], William Allen (D)[4], Henry Steincamp (D)[5], Richard Elder (E)[6], Sergeant Peter A Glass (F), Jasper Johnson (F), Benjamin Hurlby (G), Charles Lauson (G)[7], Geo. Molt (H), George Gaerger (H)[8], John Klohr (H)[9], Joseph Youngle (H)[10], Emanuel Plants (I)[11], Andrew Wanders (I), Daniel O’Conner (K) and James Wright (K).
Wounded:
First Lieutenant WU Sifford (A), Captain Andrew Nuhfer (D), Second Lieutenant Andrew Kline (H), Second Sergeant FS Gates (A), Third Sergeant John Collins (B), Fourth Sergeant James Richey (B), Corporal Emanuel D Smith (B), Wm. H Heachenburg (B), Samuel U Shutts (B), Chester A Buckland (B), Clarence Williams (B), Elisha Sprague (B), John Dardis (B), Second Sergeant Henry A Barney (B), Asa Brayton (C), William P Hailer (C), August Offel (C), Corporal John Carbaugh (D), Wm. Keil (D), Joseph Beam (D), John Stadt (D), Arthur Worseholder (D), George Albert (D), Andrew Werner (D), Fourth Sergeant Charles C Baird (E), Corporal Emanuel Fink (E), Corporal John Lodge (E), George Hazel (E), Augustus Lodge (E), Isaac Kaufman (E), Laurance Cremmering (E), William Buffington (E), Abraham Darfie (F), David Kaull (F), Second Sergeant Merritt Sexton (G), Corporal Wm. U McEnally (G), John Ammon (G), Lewis C Clark (G), John Kann (G), Rufus Lawrence (G), August Milchey (G), Frederick Schaefer (G), Jonathan Taylor (G), Henry Will (G), William M Walker (G), Jackson Bender (H), Frederick Frank (H), Nichlaus Huber (H), John Oblingen (H), Jacob Stitz (H), Sergeant AB Putnam (I), Sergeant Milton Hazzen (I), Corporal John O’Brien (I), Joseph Smith (I), Samuel Plants (I), Henry Friar (I), Ephraim Metcalf (I), Fourth Sergeant Aleck Moore (K), Peter Eagan (K), J Farrell (K), Pat. Handley (K), JJ Dugan (K), Pat. Fernan (K), J Flinn (K), Thomas Nuggins (K) and An. Terry (K).
Missing:
Second Lieutenant James Donnell (I), Sergeant William Weeks (A), T Babcock (A)[12], R Warrons (A), HB Cadwallader (A), P Ernst (A), J Foster (A), M Golden (A), E Pike (A), E Reynolds (A), B Snyder (A), Corporal Henry H Olds (B), Corporal Charles Stanton (C), Corporal David Grant (C), Matthew Degroft (D), Drummer Thomas Devins (D), Rems Whitman (D), Solomon Cook (D), Charles Johnsmyre (D), Fifth Sergeant Jacob H Farry (E), James H Gilbert (E), Jacob S Smith (E), Christian Finkbinder (E), Gideon F Draper (E), Hannon G Fortress (E), John Crofts (E), Sardis Patterson (F), Fifer HB French (G), John Flannigan (G), Michael McKarty (G), Michael Nice (H), Clemens Eckhorn (H), Charles Drumbower (H), Christian Benedict (H), Frederick Schuler (H), Joseph Shell (I), UA Dukes (I), SR Heberling (I), Charles Trego (I), W Dutton (I), Pat. Galagher (K) and Thomas Horner (K).
Other Possible Killed:[13]
Ludwig G. Miller (A), Samuel Barger (A), Jerome Van Tassell (A), Corporal John W Van Tassell (A), Adam Stoner (A), Sergeant Stephen C Aiken (B), Samuel H Shutts (B)[14], Elisha Sprague (B), August Affel (C)[15], Henry Amsbach (C), Henry Orendorf (C), John Parrish (C), John J Sevits (C), Demetrius Rood (C), Jonathan M Ladd (D), John C Nachtrieb (D), Jackson Peoples (D)[16], James Reed (D)[17], Charles H Rood (D)[18], Sergeant George W Warner (D), Wallace Main (E), William H Meng (E), Hubbard Cross (F), David H Ensminger (F), George W Reed (G), William Rood (G), John Shaddock (G), Harrison Warner (G)[19], Benjamin Thurlby (G)[20], George Frideritzi (H)[21], Louis Lehr (H), Frederick Moerder (H), George Yerger (H)[22], Jacob Stoll (H)[23], William Gilger (I) and John Stahl (I).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 152-3
[2] Listed as missing in Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Website lists as killed.
[3] Listed as missing in Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Website lists as killed.
[4] Listed in Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing as wounded. Website lists as died April 9, 1862.
[5] Listed in Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing as wounded. Website lists as died April 10, 1862. Website also lists as Steinkamp.
[6] Listed as missing in Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Website lists as killed.
[7] Listed in Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing as wounded. Website lists as died April 28, 1862.
[8] Listed in Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing as wounded. Website lists as died April 10, 1862. Website also lists as Jaerger.
[9] Listed in Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing as wounded. Website lists as died May 10, 1862. Website also lists as Glohr..
[10] Listed in Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing as wounded. Website lists as died April 16, 1862.
[11] Listed in Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing as wounded. Website lists as died April 8, 1862.
[12] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing says, “Supposed to be wounded.”
[13] This second list of killed comes from http://www.udata.com/users/hsbaker/72honor.htm. This website draws its information from Official Roster of the Soldiers of the State of Ohio in the War of the Rebellion, 1861 - 1866. The Werner PTG. and MFG. Co., Akron, Ohio, 1888. Volume VI, pages 708 - 717. Of this list of 36 men 10 are listed as having died within a month of the battle. This list though also reflects men who died of disease, not battle wounds.
[14] Died April 6, 1862.
[15] Died April 8, 1862.
[16] Died April 24, 1862.
[17] Died April 1862.
[18] Died April 10, 1862.
[19] Died April 11, 1862.
[20] Died April 6, 1862.
[21] Died April 28, 1862.
[22] Died April 10, 1862.
[23] Died April 30, 1862.
Monday, July 12, 2010
Matthew Archer
I could share a ton of pictures but I'll only bother you with three. The first is Matthew when he was just 30 minutes old.
And here is Matthew during his first evening home.
71st Ohio Infantry
Killed:
Levi Johnson (A), Frank Rontsong (B), Sergeant Richard Davis (C), Sanford S Peterson (C), Peter Wedemeyer (D), William Hawkins (D), Allen Worthington (E), Isiah Brannan (G), Spicer Canada (G), Miller Berry (H), Wm. S Bradenberg (I), Henry Martin (K), Stephen Burdo (K) and Thomas P McInwan (K).
Wounded:
Austin Johnson (A), Adam P Lehman (A), Joseph Kunkels (A), John Wilson (A), First Sergeant William Skinner (B), William J Marshall (B), LM North (B), Frank Marcurn (B), George Omart (C), Andrew Kironer (C), William Martin (C), James Knox (C), William Heston (C), Ambrose C Davis (C), Charles Sabin (D), Johnathan Swanger (D), John W Cout (D), Henry Polms (D), John Mayers (E), DA Bright (E), John Beemer (E), FC Lowe (E), Simon Wones (E), Oliver MCoule (F), Henry Canfield (G), Wm. Shively (H), Abraham Bently (H), Wm. D Addas (H), Daniel Andrews (H), Philip Stickler (H), Llusseri Frank (H), Nicholas Oberinger (H), Jesse Davis (I), James T Taylor (I), BF Cable (I), Dm. Dick (I), Frederick Reinhardt (I), Sergeant James Hays (K), Corporal WM Langdon (K), AW Roosa (K), E Drake (K), HS Astor (K), DA Bennett (K), WH Hay (K), Henry Jackman (K), Martin V Roosa (K), David Rose (K), Milson B Riely (K), Nathan B Trump (K), Thomas Webster (K), Sergeant AW Hufford (K) and Alexander Edgar (K).
Missing:
Third Corporal HH Williams (A), Sixth Corporal Lewis Platt (A), George Bridker (A), Fred. Garman (A), GW Reynolds (A), Anthony Reeder (A), John Vian (A), Sergeant Harvey V Cook (C), Henry Wrigley (C), Humphrey Roser (C), James Dickey (C), James Shell (C)[2], George W Collings (D), Urias Palmer (E), George W Gnutt (E), Wilson C Rose (E), Edward Skinner (F), Lambert Smith (F), Marion Fox (F), Thomas Ravemscraft (F), George Sims (F), Samuel McDaniel (F), Isaac Boyer (G), George W Capry (G), Wm. May (G), Henry Oswalt (G)[3], Wm. A Power (G), James Rout (G), James Sipes (G), Beonhard Switzer (G), Henry Swim (G), Frederick Lolada (G), Wm. Fester (G), John Jones (H), First Lieutenant WH McDevitt (K), Sergeant AA Brown (K), Corporal John Shaw (K), La Berans (K), Elijah Cole (K), James W Hamilton (K), Jacob Roosa (K), Frederick Roes (K) and George K Stout (K).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 123-4
[2] “Returned Sick”
[3] “Since returned and sick”
Friday, July 9, 2010
70th Ohio Infantry
Killed:
Charles L Ball (A), Andrew Morris (A), Samuel L Mchaffey (C), William Harvey (D), John Page (D), Abraham Maxwell (E), WJ Ellis (G), RS Shirley (G) and Lewis Haselbaker (K).
Wounded:
Second Lieutenant John Taylor (H), Corporal John Rainey (A), Corporal Thomas F Montgomery (A), MM Covan (A), George Dillinger (A), John W Lamender (A), Samuel R Blair (A), Lewis W Baird (A), Corporal George Ryan (B), Henry Deasley (B), Cornelius Miller (B), John M Mooman (B), Samuel Newman (B), Alexander Parker (B), John Suffron (B), Philip B Taylor (B), Thomas HB Viers (B), Corporal John Thornbury (C), James F Campton (C), Andrew J Newberry (C), Samuel Preston (C), Corporal Jacob Bogart (D), Thos. Riley (D), Jacob Haberdan (D), Christopher Haish (D), Second Sergeant Madison H Alexander (E), Third Sergeant Joseph Hamilton (E), Fourth Sergeant DD Danseth (E), First Corporal Wm. C Marlatt (E), Fifth Corporal Greenleaf N McMannis (E), John T Bower (E), Lewis Campbell (E), Wm. W Eakins (E), Samuel M Hamilton (E), Joseph Rogers (E), Second Sergeant Jasper N Sawyer (F), Corporal Presley J Lane (F), Joseph McDaniel (F), William Haines (F), WJ Shelton (F), Third Sergeant George W McKee (G), First Corporal MH Matheny (G), Third Corporal Alexander Little (G), RW Jennings (G), Nenny Krees (G), George Kramer (G), First Corporal Samuel Taylor (H), Zachariah Grooms (H), Samuel M Taylor (H), Corporal F Puthoff (I), JE Everhardt (I), Joseph M Shields (K) and John Spencer (K).
Missing:
Captain Joseph Blackburn (F), Nathan J Tucker (A), Tunis M Marsh (A), Allen Cook (B), Davis Needman (B), RJ Rotchell (C), Wm. Sprigg (C), Andrew Smalley (C), Uriah Irwin (C), John Rothwell (C), David S Taylor (C), Charles M Taylor (C), Isaac N Smith (E), Christopher Cook (E), George E McGinnes (E), George V Seerist (E), Thomas Vinsonhaller (E), John J Victor (F), Samuel Naden (F), Peter Sopst (G), George Kramer (G), First Corporal Samuel Taylor (H), Augustine Gill (H), John McEny (H), George Rape (H), Eli Stule (H), James Thornton (H), Mark O’Neil (H), Zachariah Grooms (H), Samuel Taylor (H), Corporal F Suthoff (I), Corporal William Philips (I), Thomas Davis (I), John M Mellin (I), John Bolinger (I), Andrew Miller (I), Frank Foot (I), JE Eberhardt (I), Musician JW Allen (K), Elijah Abbott (K), Joseph Baschart K(), D Johnson (K), JM Carren (K), J Mahoney (K), EW Washburn (K), Joseph M Shields (K) and John Spencer (K).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 155-6
Wednesday, July 7, 2010
59th Ohio Infantry
59th Ohio Infantry[1]
Killed:
Second Lieutenant William Johnson (E)[2], Joseph G Harris (H)[3], Daniel M Kirby (I), William W Raper (F), First Sergeant James G Sargeant (H), James A Buchanan (E), Corporal Obed Bishop (F), and First Sergeant Edwin B Ham (I).
Wounded:
Corporal Price T Fee (B), Joseph Gelvin (B), William Boyle (D), Stephen P Shinkle (D), and David Howell (G).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 206. Also Official Roster of the Soldiers of the State of Ohio in the War of the Rebellion 1861-1866. Cincinnati: Wilstach, Baldwin & Co., 1886. Vol 5, pp 213-41, 741-4.
[2] Listed as dead in Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Listed as wounded in roster.
[3] No Harris listed in roster 213-41. Joseph G Hines listed as killed in roster 213-41, but not in roster 741-4.
Monday, July 5, 2010
58th Ohio Infantry
Killed:
Haver. Hoelldorfer (A), Sergeant Charles Shaw (B), Henry Fessler (B), Sergeant David Bauer (D), Corporal Joseph Bose (E), Emanuel Shadder (E), Amos Kokley (F), Daniel Mossner (G), Sebastian Bessber (G) and Leonard Bond (K).
Wounded:
Color-bearer Corporal Frederick Bohme (A), William Alott (A), Second Lieutenant Henry Oderfeld (B), Corporal Adolph Herrmann (B), Henry Brimmer (B), Joseph Fleichans (B), Samuel Selig (B), Captain L Barentsen (C), Valentin Hank (C), Corporal Christian Ranft (C), Michael Hank (C), Bernhard Kaihold (D), Frank Kebelmayer (D), Frederick Esch (D), Louis Grethen (D), Aug. Kleigel (D), Corporal Jacob Koock (E), Christian Miller (E), Henry Steelbs (F), Corporal Nathan Burhanan (F), Jacob Burgoon (F), Ernst Kunsel (G), John Prell (G), Peter Wecke (G), Theodore Sirming (G), Jacob Kochendorfer (G), First Sergeant FH Beam (H), Joseph White (H), Corporal Henry H Diseen (I), Aquila Rice (I), Joseph McDowell (I), S Ward (I), J Putnam (I), George Ludwig (I), First Sergeant Daniel Nonneumaker (K), Robert Cane (K), George Palmer (K), Peter Voltz (K), James Mowry (K), William Keck (K) and Henry Palmer (K).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 72-4
Wednesday, June 30, 2010
57th Ohio Infantry
Killed:
Captain AC Gribben (A), James A Junghanns (E), Sergeant GW Routzer (F), Richard Campbell (A), Isaac Harris (A), Joab Hawkins (D), Richard Mahoney (I), Samuel Wood (C), Frank Soffer (K) and Joseph Zimmermann (B).
Wounded:
Sergeant Joseph McCrate (A), Arthur Harris (A), IS White (A), John Nichols (A), Mathias Beemer (A), Daniel Dickey (A), James W Smith (A), Samuel Sweeney (A), William Maybury (A), MD Tate (A), Josiah Farmer (A), Daniel Shafer (A), John Scoby (A), Calvin Baker (F), Stephen Smith (F), James C Switzer (F), Johiel Bowers (F), John Drummond (F), Marion Harris (D), George Grimes (D), Captain AS Skelton (I), WJ Latridge (I), SJ Conklin (I), Henry Welchhouce (I), Thomas Kief (I), David Bull (I), Michael Woodman (I), Captain Samuel Mott (C), Corporal Francis Gauther (C), Hamon Dawson (C), Granville Hamilton (C), George Gibbs (C), Israel Giberson (C), Phenix Hartzog (C), George Shriver (C), Michael Gross (C), First Lieutenant Hiram Henderson (H), Corporal Joseph Wolf (H), Corporal Thomas McDonough (H), Corporal Alex. Engle (H), John Carroll (H), Stephen Boren (H), Jacob Coon (H), John Martin (H), Henry Barker (H), Sergeant Robert Smith (E), Sergeant Jacob Michael (E), David Shenter (E), John Stube (E), Peter Weber (E), Fred. Wickhart (E), Corporal James McCormick (K), Melancthon Binkley (K), Alex. Brownly (K), Robert Herndon (K), Corporal Martin Beever (B), J Dunersbaugh (B), Lot Todd (B), Harrison Beaver (B), Aaron B Bosler (B), Patrick Lynch (B), Corporal Timothy Lawler (G), Corporal Nathaniel Blake (G), William Snartz (G), William Schaut (G), Samuel Walter (G), Theodore Miller (G), Phillip Berget (G) and Stephen Jones (G).
Missing:
Thomas Parish (A), John Paxton (A), Robert Foster (A), William Alspa (F), John Young (F), Thomas Lyons (D), George Kidd (D), Fred. Young (D), Sergeant William Beswick (I), Joseph McDougal (I), Fred. Picker (I), Frank Lattridge (I), William Ellen (I), Daniel Boyer (I), Jos. Haberstock (C), Harrison Kelison (C), Albert Baily (C), Austin Fuller (H), Levi Wolf (H), George Brand (H), George D Wolf (E), Nicholas Felix (E), William Doss (E), Lewis Weiss (E), Thomas Poorman (K), John Etchin (B), Thomas Feriney (B), Samuel Frederick (B) and James Strouse (B).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 132-3
Monday, June 28, 2010
54th Ohio Infantry
Killed:
Lewis Stieris (A), William Holcumb (A), Ezra J Lotham (A), Nathan Chesley (A), Henry D King (B), Allen H Lowe (B), Francis V Hale (B), Frank B Adams (B), James M Casselman (B), Lieutenant George Decharms (C), Corporal Newton Dowden (C), Jason Randall (C), John Coplin (C), John E Lusk (D), Joseph McFaggart (D), William Northouss (D), Corporal James Potter (E), Richard Allen (E), Captain Peter Bertram (F), Corporal Edward H Moon (F), Samuel Curl (F), Frank Obermeyer (F), Corporal Albert Black (G) and John Ferguson (G).
Wounded:
Sergeant Henry C Wirner (A), Sergeant Walter Hill (A), John Baker (A), Michael Cadle (A), Lyman Cail (A), Patrick Driscol (A), William Figgins (A), Joshua Fergeson (A), Gottrich Gertsner (A), Paul Jones (A), Karl Kauter (A), Michael Kurderer (A), Jefferson Lindsey (A), John Petry (A), William J Richardson (A), John M Smidt (A), Charles Smith (A), Henry Scherer (A), Sanford Luker (A), Peter Volmer (A), Elisha Williams (A), Sergeant William H Elliot (B), Corporal Cyrus Pottenger (B), Corporal Adam C Neff (B), Corporal David F Price (B), Corporal James M Anderson (B), Corporal Henry B Geff (B), Henry W Carroll (B), Thomas Davin (B), Franklin W Whiteside (B), Alonzo D Kimball (B), Andrew J Clark (B), Samuel Cook (B), Jackson VB Ford (B), John Speelman (B), Sergeant Firgus Mitchell (C), Corporal Thomas Codington (C), Corporal Edmond Updegrove (C), James M Goldsberry (C), Hugh McNeil (C), John Conner (C), John Lowell (C), Samuel Sellair (C), Oliver Vansselt (C), William Keith (C), Charles W Craig (C), John N Peacock (C), Silas M Smith (C), John Sammony (C), William Eastman (C), First Sergeant John W English (D), Sergeant William HH Shochey (D), Sergeant Lyman N Means (D), Corporal Ezra T Kent (D), Corporal William Howell (D), Corporal George Connor (D), Empire McKent (D), Charles Smith (D), William Blank (D), Joseph R Marshall (D), Joseph Mulford (D), David Unsly (D), Henry J Mulford (D), Henry Morris (D), August Duval (D), Reuben Haywood (D), John R Hutchinson (D), FG Davis (D), John Weaver (D), Sergeant Seman W Bander (E), Sergeant Lewis Burnam (E), Sergeant Horace S Button (E), Corporal Hugh Moncreif (E), Corporal Lyman McGath (E), Charles Olmstead (E), William Maloy (E), Charles Dalley (E), James Hudson (E), George F Gale (E), Andrew J Brewer (E), Horace Knapp (E), John C Shoemaker (E), Frederick Meagley (E), Sergeant James Parks (F), Corporal Jacob Kitt (F), Corporal Joseph Kerr (F), Corporal Charles H Nicol (F), Musician Samuel Hull (F), Joseph Freisens (F), Joseph Lawrence (F), William Miller (F), John Trimbur (F), Henry Whetsel (F)[2], Captain Albert Rogall (G), Sergeant Absalom Borror (G), Corporal Charles H Caho (G), Corporal Charles F Beall (G), Mitchell Bradley (G), James WW Pottle (G), Charles Popense (G), John Quigley (G), David H Brice (G), Sergeant JW Shuffleton (H), Corporal M Kirby (H), Corporal J Dillon (H), George Knoer (H), O Clegg (H), J Hill (H), JG Hank (H), Andrew Jackson (H), Jacob Jackson (H), David R Milner (H), M Smith (H), W Wilbur (H), Lieutenant Luther Saxton (I), Sergeant J Dolin (I), WH Pierce (I), Eber Allen (I), N Nutt (I), John High (I), John Drury (I), Sergeant Cary Rockhold (I), Sergeant LG Huff (K), Sergeant George Russell (K), RW Surface (K), John Marshall (K), George Norris (K), Martin Bannon (K) and Ebenezer Little (K).
Missing:
John Shoemaker (A), Isaac Abner (A), John Roach (A), John H Smith (A), Gratius Smith (A), Peter Tammory (C), John Damon (C), William Black (C), Sergeant Joseph Ward (D), Charles S Grace (D), Dallas Whitney (E), Reuben Mitchell (E), Joseph Rexinger (E), Thomas Gahon (E), Patrick Hart (E), James Sytle (E), Joseph McCarty (E), Sergeant William G Harper (F), Corporal Jacob Snyder (F), Charles Beedlove (F), John Racey (F), Belser Schmitt (F), George Huff (F), Corporal James W Beall (G), William Dolan (G), Hiram Stokes (G), Sergeant JH Peebles (H), Samuel Baggs (H), Philip Belt (H), James Schnider (H), Hugh E Williams (H) and William Myers (K).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 116-8
[2] Also missing.
Friday, June 25, 2010
53th Ohio Infantry
Killed:
Charles L Winterton (A), Richard E Shephard (A), Jacob Prig (A), Francis Smith (F), John Rose (F), Benjamin Woods (I) and Daniel McLeary (K).
Wounded:
Sergeant George W Eddy (A), Sergeant Gilbert R Sopshire (A), Corporal John McLay (A), AT Jenkins (A), A Wade (A), WJ Hopper (A), Sergeant Joel G Woolman (B), George Burton (B), Hugh Thomas (B), John Welch (C), Sergeant Thomas McFarland (E), George Russel (E), Smith Cox (E), Reuben Smather (E), Corporal James N House (F), Nathan Adams (F), William J Bowers (F), AW Chenoweth (F), Austin Cottril (F), Jordan Deal (F), August D Maloon (F), Jos. A Mackey (F), Daniel Yerian (F), LE Booth (F), Corporal Daniel Beasley (G), William Campbell (G), Second Lieutenant JH Lasley (H), Corporal Elisha B Meek (H), Jacob Himan (H), Corporal SS Fultz (H), Daniel Neal (I), First Sergeant EF McAroy (K) and RW Darrah (K).
Missing:
John Carrigan (C), John W Weeks (C), Aaron Butler (E), Daniel Wells (F), Charles H Watson (H), JR Mathews (H), Jos. Garrick (K) and Emanuel Schreider (K).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 133-4
Wednesday, June 23, 2010
49th Ohio Infantry
Killed:
GL Williamson (A), Corporal Thomas McBride (B), Calvin Bonersock (B), Thomas Fisher (C), Oliver H Robison (D) and Lewis Wood (E).
Wounded:
Joseph Dietz (A), Daniel Wise (A), LH Harvie (A), SH Dixon (A), Jacob Grindle (A), Charles Wetherbee (A), Orderly Sergeant James Redmond (B), Corporal George W Poats (B), Corporal OP Boygart (B), Corporal Thomas Smith (B), George W Waggoner (B), William Stevenson (B), JW Rintz (B), Freeman Hurs (B), Andrew Berkett (B), Samuel Hayer (C), Alford Heitshew (D), DS Elder (D), AC Gregg (D), William Nichols (D)[2], Hecassa Musgraves (D)[3], Charles Franks (E), Sergeant Levi Laughlin (F), Corporal CC Laughlin (F)[4], James Stoner (F), John H Stoner (F), WS Flangher (F), TI Mercer (F), John Wise (G), George Babbitt (G), IS Grames (G), Eli Butler (I) and WHH Ingle (K).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 257-8, 262-3
[2] Listed as William Hickles on page 258.
[3] Listed as Micajah Musgraves on page 258.
[4] Is included in the regimental list of wounded from April 10 on page 262 but is not in the brigade list from April12 on page 238.
Tuesday, June 22, 2010
Sorry for the absence of late
So hopefully I'll be able to give the blog the time it deserves again. One thing I want to do right off the bat is do some short book reviews. You can see to the right that there is quite a few books that I've read for Civil War News. All of those reviews have been written, I'm just waiting for them to be published in the newspaper and then I'll post the whole review here. In the meantime though I wanted to give a short review of those books on here so that you would not have to wait months to find out if the book is worthwhile. Those short reviews will be the next thing I start putting on here.
And we're in the home stretch for the baby's arrival. They will definitely induce on July 1st if the baby has not arrived by then. At the beginning of June I thought for sure the baby would come before July 1st but now I'm thinking that he is going to be an ornery child and will arrive on July 1st. And long ago we decided on Matthew Archer. We liked Matthew and then my wife decided she would be open to a Civil War connected middle name. So one night I pulled Coddington's Gettysburg off the shelf and read her the order of battle. She liked Archer, for Confederate General James Archer. I wanted Braxton for Braxton Bragg, who I think was not nearly as bad as everyone makes him out. But Archer sounds good and as it turns out Archer is probably best remembered for being the first Confederate general in Lee's army to be captured and it happened on July 1st by the 2nd Wisconsin. So besides having a Civil War connection we will also have a connection to Wisconsin (where all my family is from) might also have a connection to July 1st.
Monday, June 21, 2010
48th Ohio Infantry
Killed:
Clement Tudor (A), David Morgan (A), Captain WL Warner (B), Aaron Sales (B), Alex. S Malott (B), Elias J Hill (B), Jesse Nelson (C), Salathiel Hallam (D), Peter Cravens (D), John W Canter (D), Sergeant JJ Duncan (E), Richard Smith (G), Stephen Workman (H),
William Kratzer (I), Jacob Thomas (I) and Hiram S Manchester (K).
Wounded:
Colonel Peter J Sullivan, Lieutenant FM Posegare (A), Sergeant William Willis (A), Thomas M Wright (A), Corporal GR Conrad (A), Corporal IDF Williams (A), JW Spurlock (A), JW Leeka (A), BW Lad (A), Daniel Williams (A), WC Edwards (A), Lieutenant JW Lindsay (B), Lieutenant DR Plyley (B), Sergeant John D Nevius (B), Sergeant Israel Fuller (B), Corporal Elisha Reddich (B), Corporal S Brundridge (B), Corporal William H Harvey (B), William James (B), Stephen J Winter (B), Simeon Sales (B), David C Harbaugh (B), James Brewer (B), James Hinby (B), Watson Karr (B), Sergeant William Pratt (C), C Chambers (C), JC Hamentree (C), Boone Hogan (C), Amos Layman (C), Jacob Lippolt (C), S Raines (C), James Seal (C), James Vaupelt (C), LA Williams (C), Albert West (D), AL Adams (D), H Cox (D), S Cox (D), John J Lynch (D), Thos. Nelson (D), B McDonald (D), John P McElwain (D), Wm. Carter (D), Wm. Henderson (D), James Whirley (D), Corporal Henry Said (E), A Bartz (E), Frank Cunningham (E), Isaac Fox (E), Henry Hilderbrandt (E), DR Lindsmith (E), Obed Macy (E), Jason Penny (E), George Morrison (F), WG Cole (F), Fred. W Holtzel (F), James Myers (F), Robert Cosgrove (F), William H Doudd (F), Chris. Noyle (F), Edwin Cory (F), FM Smith (F), William A Combs (G), Captain John E Bond (H), Corporal Joshua Tudor (H), JW Bardsley (H), William Brown (H), RN Hughey (H), David Manter (H), R Waters (H), Orderly Sergeant Philip M Everhard (I), Corporal Cornelius Turner (I), M Edwards (I), EJ Hill (I), Corporal BC Bowan (K), A McAvoy (K), John Heitzman (K), WJ Hilms (K), John McKenzie (K), William B Lang (Band), EM Henry (Band), WT Purdy (Band) and EV Brehney (Band).
Missing:
Charles Rodgers (A).
Report omits missing but does give a list of the number for each company. Company A, 1; Company B, 5; Company C, 11; Company D, 2; Company E, 8; Company F, 7 Company G, 1; Company H, 8; Company I, 4; Company K, 2; Total, 49.
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 154-5.
Friday, June 18, 2010
46th Ohio Infantry
Killed:
Captain HH Geary (D), George Bear (D), James White (D), Lieutenant Hiram B Wilson (G), Dallas Merchant (G), Theodore Woodruff (G), Levi Millington (G), Samuel Millington (G), Sergeant John Rowles (C), David Taylor (C), Lewis Walmire (C), William Guge (C), EM Shaw (C), John Stewart (C), Sergeant Benjamin F Hasson (F), Corporal Eli Swartz (F), Silas Roby (F), Nicholas Nan (F), Jerome W Fields (F), HW Proctor (F), James M Church (H), Wilson P Smith (H), MJ Gibbons (H), Martin Regner (H), Bruce E Brown (H), Sergeant Philip B Glen (K), William Dermston (K), Corporal Henry C Stiles (B), George W Finks (B), Joseph South (B), HC Burr (E), Joel Stuttle (E), Eli Baker (E), John Brown (I) and Alexander Jeremob (I).
Wounded:
Corporal George Frankenburgh (D), A McGill (D), DO Smith (D), Jacob Shilling (D), Corporal Tho. Tansy (G), Richard Spindler (G), E Wood (G), Joseph Campbell (G), John G Paul (G), Asa McCammack (G), Phillip Sutton (G), John King (G), Joseph T Barnes (G), Joseph Clossin (G), David Cam (G), Sergeant EW Pettill (C), Corporal Thomas Batson (C), Corporal William Noble (C), Corporal M Leohner (C), Corporal James Carine (), David Busuff (), Devill Culp (), DS Evans (C), Geo. Harrison (C), Jacob Hare (C), AG Martin (C), Miles McGeoown (C), DM Noe (C), George Parkinson (C), Frank Smith (C), James Thompson (C), George Wise (C), RM Yontz (C), William Yontz (C), James Kyner (F), Christian Zools (F), Daniel Shelter (F), Joseph Cherry (F), John Broyls (F), Thomas McKierman (F), John Oriley (F), John Kitter (F), John Stephenson (F), Thomas Williams (F), John Carran (F), Benjamin Winchester (F), George Presly (F), Lieutenant John Ramsey (H), Sergeant AA McConnell (H), Sergeant Michael A Sibley (H), Sergeant Joseph Amos (H), Corporal Joseph Alexander (H), HG Afflick (H), John Hays (H), M Ham (H), Alfred Koch (H), WH Newland (H), Benedick Lery (H), John D Reed (H), William Sayne (H), Samuel Richards (H), Corporal James E Gowans (H), Corporal Theodore F Cook (H), Corporal Martin Myers (H), Corporal Caleb Roberts (K), Corporal John W Holston (K), Corporal Jackson Balding (K), Isaac Dilbone (K), N Donfon (K), John Greaves (K), William E Ireland (K), Robert Ireland (K), Nathan Lewis (K), Tilman Lewis (K), John T McCollough (K), John Miller (K), James H Watson (K), George H Danel (K), John Gressler (K), Abram Delving (K), Patrick Conlin (K), Danel Hyshire (K), William Heathcoate (K), William H Hollis (K), Alfred Risner (K), Henry Weaver (K), Thomas M Galleher (K), William Zimmerman (K), D Hepshire (K), WO Bodle (K), Sergeant John W Williams (B), Corporal George M Carter (B), Henry Weller (B), Owen Mansfield (B), Elias McKinney (B), John A Swenk (B), William Shine (B), Charles Wallace (B), E Williams (B), Lieutenant WW Watts (E), J Brentlmyer (E), Alexander Coon (E), H Boswell (E), B Clark (E), H Fellows (E), William Jones (E), H Shuttle (E), William Wallinbayer (E), William Thomas (E), Edward Lebring (E), William Hines (E), J Andur (E), T Fryer (E), J Muslin (E), C Skeels (E), A Wright (E),
Corporal Joseph Fishey (I), John Atwater (I), George H Bethard (I), Jackson Crowell (I), Adam Mont (I), John Stales (I), Jetho Hall (I), Joshua Gipe (I), Henry Waterman (I), Philip Burtes (A), WH King (A), James W Tullis (A), Am. Trubey (A), George Dumfon (A), Daric P Dunothan (A), AB Bivion (A), A Croghan (A), John Boraff (A), John Heppeand (A), Joseph Murtomire (A), John Horner (A), Enoch Thomas (A), William Lytle (A) and Henry Hoots (A).
Missing:
Sergeant Wm. S Dalton (D), Andrew L Bancroft (D), James Blair (D), William Hempy (D), Jacob Heartman (D), L Zimmerman (D), Andrew Sheredon (D), Christ. Angle (D), Lewis Bowman (G), James Baker (G), Henry Farman (G), Jacob Kissel (G), Elisha A Hunt (G), Thomas Hearst (G), Thomas Jamieson (G), Jesse Milen (G), Samuel Rees (G), Joshua Robinson (G), Joseph Wright (G), John Herron (G), Owen Hill (C), William Snieder (C), JW Hanson (C), Mothen Wyckoff (C), AF Wise (C), BF Gontz (F), William Bennett (F), Jacob N Cly (F), John Cook (F), Francis Johnson (F), John McDonough (F), Dennis O’Niel (F), Paulmas Massey (F), Corporal John Engle (H), Corporal Peter Hughes (H), Bernard Balding (K), Archibald Casteel (K), Lemuel Swift (K), Otho Fox (K), William Greaves (K), James F Kibley (B), Charles Constock (E), T Coats (E), J Brown (E), Cal. Hayes (E), William Suddith (I), Andrew Noland (I), Eli Hatfield (I), Elijah Hastings (I), Dahel Wallet (A), Ailer. Williams (A) and Thomas McGlothin (A).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 159-61
Wednesday, June 16, 2010
41st Ohio Infantry
Killed:
Horace B Ames (A), Augustus F Deeyer (A), John Ward (A), AJ Rice (F), Sergeant OP Killmer (F), SH Tillitosn (I), Fred. Hartman (I), Henry Reed (I), Sergeant J Dunn (C), Second Lieutenant CH Talcott (C), J Sweny (C), J Weaver (C), S Wagner (C), Corporal J Rossiter (C), William H Porter (H), Mathias Chamberlain (H), Seneca A Camp (H), Corporal John Cullen (E), James Labier (E), Anthony Montviel (E), J Ruschen (K), Sergeant GE Terrill (B), Sergeant John Hansard (B) and GS Bartlett (B).
Wounded:
First Lieutenant James McCleery (A), Sergeant Davis C Fuller (A), Sergeant Elmer Moses (A), Clinton Bacon (A), Samuel Bennett (A), Orlando N Haynes (A), Willford Richmond (A), Charles H Bennett (A), Captain E Opdycke (A), Sergeant Augustus D Duny (A), Corporal Sheldon Brooks (A), Alfred Frost (A), Henry Barber (A), Wallace W Braden (A), Andrew C Parker (A), Harrison Darly (A), Albert Faber (F), Mathias Hageman (F), Fred Bencher (F), Joseph Buvia (F), DP Duer (F), John Echenroad (F), J Goff (F), Wash. Gornia (F), Henry Herriff (F), OL Huran (F), Charles Newton (F), Frank Shirley (F), John Standon (F), Homer Spaulding (F), William Wetzel (F), Captain DS Leslie (F), Corporal WH Flish (D), William Glosgor (D), Benjamin Needham (D), Sergeant Burr Fisher (D), Corporal Daniel Trohidge (D), Hugh Hart (D), John Gardner (D), A Emerson (D), Corporal WD Gill (I), SP Baldwin (I), George Fields (I), Corporal William W Baker (I), Corporal Charles A Close (I), Corporal Lewis Duvio (I), Corporal John W Hall (I), Corporal EC Troutman (I), Sergeant William McClanathan (I), GA Kamer (I), William Walker (I), Captain A Wiley (C), First Lieutenant FE Pancoast (C), S Bonham (C), D Cochlin (C), T Robison (C), Corporal JW Clark (C), E Leninger (C), W Chaffin (C), A Hummed (C), S Lautzenbetzer (C), J Carlin (C), J Gallaway (C), S Graybill (C), Sergeant L Reed (C), Corporal Edwin R Lurland (H), Corporal SB Chapman (H), Corporal John George Mills (H), Lester A Masho (H), Henry West (H), George T Whitney (H), Acting Second Lieutenant AE Virgil (E), Corporal Thomas Peners (E), Samuel Colby (E), Michael Chalb (E), Edward Fitzpatrick (E), Ensign Fulweller (E), David Phillips (E), John Gordon (E), Daniel Hogan (E), John Hayes (E), Mitchell Miller (E), Corporal William Edwards (E), Benjamin Wood (E), Corporal Jos. Bond (K), LM Lovelace (K), Dennis Sexton (K), John Pendleton (K), Corporal John M Obrien (K), Sergeant HP Wolcott (K), Edward M Cowdrey (K), BW Earl (K), WHH Oshin (K), Charles Miller (K), John Stewart (K), Sexton Taylor (K), Andrew Winters (K), Corporal A Hosmer (B), William Farrel (B), Theodore Hawley (B), M Gager (B), OC Weber (B), P Parks (B), A McNish (B), R Benton (B), M Worden (B), D Cowless (B), M Cottain (B) and Captain WR Tolles (B).
Missing:
Joseph Eay (I).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 196-7
Monday, June 14, 2010
24th Ohio Infantry
Killed:
CF Trowbridge (A), EC Peck (A), Sergeant Francis Atkinson (B), HH Dawman (B), WH Bailey (D), John W Severs (D), WH Swagner (D), Simon Deggenger (H), Benjamin Davidson (I), Corporal Jacob Stricker (K) and Musician David R Norris (K).
Wounded:
Major AS Hall, Palmer Whitney (A), EP Kinney (A), A McGlaughlin (A), Corporal Charles B Davis (A), J Holman (A), Isaac Furman (A), JW Smeed (A), George W Thompson (A), Corporal DG Hemmenway (A), Corporal Henry Carr (A), First Lieutenant Lafayette Foster (B), Eugene Sullivan (B), WH Clayton (B), Michael Shakert (B), George B Sparks (B), Sergeant David Thomas (D), Corporal Daniel Emery (D), Thomas F Guthrie (D), Alva Cooper (D), James G Runnels (D), Wm. H Sample (D), First Lieutenant Paul Spohn E), First Sergeant Andrews (E), Henry Monnehan (E), Jerome Stall (E), Sergeant John H Volcar (E), Corporal WHH Miller (E), WH Miller (E), Henry Cook (E), Alanson Kennedy (E), John W Wilson (E), Charles G DeLong (E), Corporal Thomas J Moody (E), Corporal EF Gray (E), JH Robinson (E), Sergeant Coleman Ermin (G), Martin Frederickson (G), Henry Feese (G), Thomas G Stutsfield (G), Joseph C Tritner (G), Joel H Richel (G), Paul Hagler (G), Captain George Arnold (H), Corporal William Crytzenburg (H), Andrew Helbranner (H), John Weinest (H), John F Wygold (H), Fred. Crystus (H), Christian Craymer (H), Andrew Charles (I), George Charles (I), James Lyons (I), Captain TM McClure (K), Corporal Anstides D Green (K), Chauncey Trimble (K), Matthew Campbell (K), William Douglass (K) and Samuel DeCamp (K).
Missing:
John Coleman (A), Sergeant Isaac C Smith (B), Sergeant George B Howard B), Corporal Charles H Draper (B), Musician George WB Dixon (B), Robert Grim (B), Joseph Kelly (B), John Stone (B), Henry J Smith (B), William Walcut (B), Doc. B Sherman (F), Mathew Sargeant (F), George Loaks (G), Sergeant Wilhelm Mouche (H), Barnhart Leon (H), Leopold Epstein (H), Wilhelm Amberg (H), Henreich Hoyer (H), William Wagner (H), John Wiggins (K) and Joseph Wackerles (K).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 194-5
Friday, June 11, 2010
20th Ohio Infantry
Wednesday, June 9, 2010
19th Ohio Infantry
Killed:
Major Timothy Dwight Edwards, OF Powell (C), Horace H Bailey (C), First Lieutenant CR Tate (D), Second Lieutenant William A Southerland (H)[2] and Corporal William Gibson (H).
Wounded:
Milton Highland (A), John Stevens (B), John C Hulber (B), Corporal John Sherman (C), Corporal Andrew Cutter (C), JL Davis (C), William Leiviett (C), John Masters (C), CJ Talbitzer (C), WE Haight (C), Fifth Sergeant Ancil B Mayhew (D), GG Bradley (D), Enoch T Johnson (D), William T Morgan (D), Solomon D Tyler (D), Abraham Davis (E), Sergeant Emuel Garver (F), William Evans (G), John W Green (G), GF Gonder (G), James Graham (G), A Harrngton (G), Fisher McKee (G), Lester S Onatt (G), First Sergeant James H Jenny (H), Abram J Kirk (H), George Ducomman (H), James Lynch (H), Charles Ducarty (H), Corporal Green (I), AC Davis (I), A Ritter (I), Robert Patterson (I), John F Rudy (I), George W Lea (I), John Wagoner (I), Ira Whalen (I), BF Warner (I), Corporal William Beatty (K), Elmer Barney (K), Benjamin Cross (K), Sherman Lane (K), Valentine Mammel (K), Anderson Oviatt (K), William Penkale (K), Dwight Shumway (K), Benjamin Lanacoll (K) and George Fluke (K).
Missing:
Corporal William Sheffer (C), Miller Wilson (C), Adam Kepler (F), Michael Lenhart (F), Edward Steward (G), John Adams (H) and James Sweeney (H).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 206, 209-10
[2] Listed as wounded on 210, listed as mortally wounded on 206.
Monday, June 7, 2010
15th Ohio Infantry
Killed:
Reuben Hissong (C), Corporal Stacy B Craft (E), Corporal Joseph Hewitson (E), John Campbell (E), James McCarahan (F), James McB Dickey (G), Martin B Leedy (G), William N Beach (G) and Alanson Herrick (K).
Wounded:
Sergeant James S Boyd (A), Robert Hammond (A), Jacob Krissanger (A), John Fleming (A), Samuel W McClenahan (B), Alfred C Gleave (B), Alonzo Milner (B), William Tandy (B), James Carnes (B), John Howell (B), John Frazier (B), William H McFarland (B), Milton Salmon (B), Simon Sines (B), Sergeant Thomas C Davis (C), Corporal WA Rogers (C), Joel Miller (C), William Markwent (C), Hiram Moorehouse (C), Reuben Davis (C), Enoch Numbers (C), David Thuma (C), Color Sergeant William H Mufferd (D), Caleb A Hersen (D), Orderly Sergeant John H Thompson (E), EP Meecham (E), William Smith (E), Sergeant John W Harris (E), Corporal Hugh Douglas (E), Levi Borock (F), Corporal James Barnet (F), George Porterfield (F), George Wilson (F), David Miles (F), Corporal William F Curtis (G), Corporal William Wood (G), Wilson Barnes (G), BF Cline (G), John Gardner (G), Henry S Robinson (G), William H Shade (G), Hiram P Hagerman (G), Philip C Haflick (G), Jeremiah Mackley (G), Jacob Stauffer (G), Corporal H Dennison (H), Christian Harnley (H), George Myers (H), Corporal Luke Scott (H), Reuben Crowcan (H), Philip Beamer (H), C Haverstick (H), George Gates (H), Jackson Stewart (H), Nathan Balding (H), Captain AC Cummins (I), Corporal E Levensprie (I), Daniel Gresman (I), Giles Fillet (K), Sampson G Haines (K), Levi Atkins (K), John Ridgeway (K), Corporal William Porterfield (K), John Bendure (K) and James H Bendure (K).
Missing:
Charles Williams (E) and John T Mercer (E).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 257, 265-6
Thursday, June 3, 2010
13th Ohio Infantry
Killed:
Corporal Silas Kimball (D), Felix Fields (D), Godfrey Elber (H), William Carrick (H), Richard Miller (H), Jacob Beigler (E), Andrew Schorn (E), Peter Brown (K), Henry Miller (K), Henry Corkwell (B) and Daniel Smith (B).
Wounded:
Major Benjamin Pratt Renkle, Azel I Clark (D), PE Lockwood (I), Dennison Miller (I), Mercer Wadlington (I), WB Haines (I), J Bethard (I), J Atkinson (I), Captain JR Gardner (F), Second Lieutenant Charles Lindenberg (F), T Lake (F), JJ Smith (F), J Brown (F), Allison Scott (F), Anthony Walters (F), Captain Reason R Henderson (H), Corporal William Scott (H), Jehu Young (H), Samuel C Miller (H), Christopher Cannady (H), Thomas Giles (H), Edward Kittering (H), Horace Updegroff (H), Captain OI Lemmon (C), JH Snauffer (C), Alden A Cook (C), EP Brown (C), Sergeant Aden H Wood (C), Ernest Rock (E), William Rock (E), Alvis Steines (E), Charles Banck (E), Sergeant Zeba M Stevens (K), Corporal Herman Fleigel (K)[2], JH Costas (K), Robert Wood (K), George H Knight (K), Henry Schimeller (K), Henry Oterhaus (K), John Caldwell (B), George Campbell (B), James Busick (B), John Hughes (B), John Jones (B), E Rickey (B), Patrick Sulivan (B), Michael Murphy (B) and William Cruthers (B).
Missing:
Ciprian L Irwin (D), Clement Blerger (I), Corporal Thomas Vasser (F), William Durflinger (F) and Emmett Durflinger (F).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 206, 218-9
[2] Also missing.
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
symposium ticket sales
Brooks Simpson, author of “Ulysses S. Grant: Triumph Over Adversity, 1822-1865,” will provide an overview of Grant the general.
Peter Cozzens, author of many books on Western Theater battles (among others), will talk about the relationship between Grant and Rawlins.
Although Grant led men in battle before Shiloh that battle is his first real test of army command in big battle. Wiley Sword, author of “Shiloh: Bloody April,” will discuss Grant's performance in this battle.
Grant’s Vicksburg Campaign is what really separates him from the rest of the prominent generals. John Marszalek, Executive Director and Managing Editor of the Ulysses S. Grant Association, will cover this complicated campaign. Grant's papers are also now available online.
Gordon Rhea, author “Cold Harbor: Grant and Lee, May 26–June 3, 1864,” rounds out the panel with a presentation on Grant as General-in-Chief.
The day will end with a panel discussion and time for books to be signed. As always there will be a book room with a ton of good books and deals.
Tickets will be $50 again, which also includes a continental breakfast and lunch. Last year we also gave away "The New Civil War Handbook" by Mark Hughes free to all attendees.
If you have any questions please contact us at RockyMtnCWRT at aol dot com.
Tuesday, June 1, 2010
6th Ohio Infantry
Killed:
Henry C Nordman (I) and Wm. H Brocksmith (F).
Wounded:
August Schneitman (G), Henry Taulman (G), James B Fairchild (A), Wm. Boyd (C) and Corporal Abram K Lemmon (E).
Missing:
John Wilson (B) and John Hogue (B).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 193
Friday, May 28, 2010
1st Ohio Infantry
Killed:
John Mullen (F) and William M Roads (G).
Wounded:
Lieutenant EJ Hooker (A), Fist Sergeant E Homan (A), Martin Schopp (A), GW Carroll (A), William Schultz (A), J Hassen (A), William Morris (A), Captain L Kuhlman (B), Sergeant O Gron (B), P Leob (B), Julius Miller (B), Joseph Seibold (B), Daniel Heinz (B), Charles Weber (B), William Hornell (B), M Reif (B), GL Heiks (C), John Blair (C), H Waymiere (C), W Watkins (C), Thomas Westerman (C), Corporal William Prentiss (D), SM Beasby (D), L Slagle (E), M Hannahan (F), Charles Vanshoick (F), Daniel Logan (F), James Day (G), JA Thornton (G), Thomas Scott (H), James Wallace (H), D Millhizer (H), DM Hana (H), H Stiver (H), E Finly (H), James Piles (H), H Gordon (I), W Taylor (I), J Lunon (I), CW Nelson (I), M Dessellen (I), A Gamble (I), JS Murphy (K), A Crowley (K), HP Chambers (K) and John Mercer (K).
Missing:
John Bolender (B).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 252-3
Thursday, May 27, 2010
1st Nebraska Infantry
1st Nebraska Infantry[1]
Killed:
John Raggensack (B), Sergeant W.P. Swiggett (F), Sergeant James E. Cox (H) and Corporal John Benson Thompson (I).
Wounded:
William H. Bates (A), Algernon H. Pratt (A), James S. Sweine (A), Albert E. Tegrio (A), Corporal Henry Buhren (B), John Hanson (B), Mathew Meryen (B), Chase (C), Curtis (C), Corporal James C. Miller (C), Corporal William H. Tucker (C), First Lieutenant Lee P. Gillett (D), Second Lieutenant Charles Provost (D), First Lieutenant S.M. Curran (E), Charles Dunk (E), J.R. Hutton (E), Sergeant Reeves (E), F. Rittenhouse (E), J. Scoles (F), Smith P. Tuttle (F), Captain John McConihe (G), First Lieutenant T.J. Weatherwax (G), John Beard (H) and Levi Sager (H).
[1] Reports of Officers in Relation to a Recent Battle at Pittsburg Landing. Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint, 1977. Originally published as U.S. 37th Congress, 2nd session, 1861-1862. Senate. Executive Documents Printed by Order of the Senate of the United States for the Second Session of the Thirty-Seventh Congress, 1861-62. 6 vols. Washington D.C., 1861. pp 68-9
Friday, May 21, 2010
Army of the Potomac
For whatever reason I decided to respond to him instead of ignoring him and asked him what those changes were. He claimed the army command commanders as McClellan, Pope, McClellan, Burnside, Hooker and Meade. I pointed out that Pope was never in command of the Army of the Potomac and McClellan never was removed from command. His response was citing a letter from McClellan that he felt he was a man without an army. I don't doubt he felt that way but he was never officially removed from command. Of course the author should discuss this incident in the book but he should also make clear that the Army of the Potomac troops serving under Pope were a temporary attachment, although if Pope had won the Battle of Second Manassas it might have been made permanent.
A secondary point if one wanted to quibble is that the changes of McClellan, Pope, McClellan, Burnside, Hooker and Meade is only five changes. The author stated six changes. When I first heard six changes I was pretty sure he was going to include Pope as an army commander. I wondered though if he would call McDowell the first army commander (while technically incorrect most historians have listed him as such) or if he would claim that Grant was really the army commander in 1864-65 as Meade's influence on army movements was severely curtailed.
The changes the author claims for general-in-chief are even more bizarre. I could think of Scott, McClellan, Halleck and Grant. The author claims it as Scott, McClellan, Lincoln, Halleck, Lincoln and Halleck, Lincoln, Lincoln and Halleck, Grant. General-in-chief refers to the senior army officer, Lincoln was not a general and President, he was commander-in-chief. Lincoln was very hands on, Halleck complained that he was really a military advisor implementing the wishes of Lincoln and Stanton. There was a period between McClellan and Halleck that there was no general-in-chief, but to call Lincoln that is an error. The author would need to explain in the text that Lincoln operated without a general-in-chief for awhile. Also I do not remember a time when Halleck was suspended from command as general-in-chief or that Lincoln said "we're now co-general-in-chief."
Was the marketing email simply over stating facts to make the number of changes more impressive? Maybe. I'm worried though that when given a chance to back pedal and explain that he really knew that Pope was not a commander of the Army of the Potomac and that Lincoln was not general-in-chief the author refused and doggedly stuck to his guns that he was right on all counts. It makes me worry that there are similar errors in the other command and structure changes enumerated in the book.
I confirmed through amazon that it is a self-published book, which by itself doesn't set off red flags but one of the benefits of using a publishers is that many others read the book before its published. In this case I think peer review was missing.
Needless to say I will not be buying this book. If my local library happens to get a copy I'll probably look at it but I definitely would not use it as a source until I made an extended effort to confirm anything he said.
***UPDATE 5-25-10***
Enough people have emailed asking for the title, so I'll add it here as well. The book in question is "The Ever-Changing Leaders and Organization of the Army of the Potomac" by George S. Maharay. I have also since requested the book thru ILL, only one copy was listed on worldcat which is probably not a good sign.
Thursday, May 20, 2010
Grant's Papers
Having the papers online is a fantastic resource. It helped me solve two riddles almost immediately. One was that at Shiloh the first staff member to give Lew Wallace an order was A.S. Baxter. All sources only use his initials, its a small riddle but I wanted to use his full name in a project if possible, and I found it (Algernon). The second riddle was that I had a source that claimed Grant wrote a letter to Alfred Mathews, but I did not know when. The letter appeared in a footnote in the Papers which I would not have had the patience to search for manually but now that the Papers are digitized online it took only a few minutes to solve that riddle.
I'll use it a lot on future research projects. In the past the only copy I knew of locally was a half hour drive downtown. I hardly ever have the time anymore to get there so this is a really helpful resource for me.
To search the collection yourself click here
Wednesday, May 19, 2010
Sickles at Gettysburg

Tuesday, May 18, 2010
Shiloh Maps
Monday, May 17, 2010
Chickamauga Maps
They did this in conjunction with the publication of "The Battles of Chickamauga and Chattanooga and the Organizations Engaged" by Henry Boynton, edited by Timothy B. Smith. Smith has basically combined three Boytnon books into one volume and provided some other notes on Boynton. I have not held a copy of Smith's version yet, I knew he was working on it but did not realize it was out already. I actually do have Boynton's other books but I would like a modern reprint so I don't have to worry about ruining my 100 year old versions.
Wednesday, May 5, 2010
Life
And of course there is the more important things like trying to get ready for the baby. The doctor intends to induce labor at the end of June so a July 1st birth is quite likely. The nursery is nearly ready. We've been waiting for the crib to arrive, apparently we selected the slowest company in the world, this Saturday it'll be 17 weeks since we ordered it. Then I can hang some pictures and shelves on the walls and get things finished. Last weekend was the baby shower so now most things we need are here. I think all we're really missing is a high chair and we can wait on that for a little while.
Things should clear up next week after the round table presentation. And then hopefully by the end of the month the manuscript will be complete. So once I start to free up times for better posts the baby will come and the blog will be the furthest thing from my mind. I'll try to build up a supply of posts so that there won't be a precipitate drop off here in July.
Thanks for your understanding.